Thursday, September 22, 2011

Give me the magic youtube video

Amy just stepped into my office to discuss a prevalent theme in the Energy 1 - Personal Energy Understanding Narratives. She is noticing that many of the teachers are mentioning a desire for specific prompts/demos/videos to catalyze student engagement with energy ideas. I think I can empathize with the teachers on this one. The level of engagement and productive discourse in our Energy workshops is consistently very impressive to me. I would like to see similar engagement in my energy course for college freshmen which begins tomorrow. Part of me is looking for just the right prompt/demo/video to spark this engagement. Unfortunately, another part of me knows that the prompt is only a small piece of instructional context which enables excellent engagement and discourse. Productive discourse depends on a wide array of subtle and elusive factors that characterize the learning community. Certainly, one of the most significant factors is the learners themselves. Teachers happen to be a group which is pre-disposed toward engagement with the learning process. College freshmen will be different, pre-college students will be different. Nevertheless, I believe we can identify a number of coherent and generalizable strategies for creating and nurturing a climate which is conducive to production scientific engagement. This is a significant goal of the teaching seminar this coming academic year.

1 comment:

  1. Lane,

    Can I encourage you to: (a) turn this into a research question (more on this below), and (b) share it on the Energy Project Scholars blog?

    Regarding (a), I find it of academic interest that teachers who are engaged in such rich discourse and engagement in E1 or E2 would say that what they want from us is a YouTube video or a demo. (Maybe they say this because they feel they have all of the other resources from 'us' that they need, or maybe they say it because they just don't 'get' all the other subtle things involved in engaging students in rich, disciplinary discourse.) If you are going to make this a focus of the AYPD course, I think you should leverage the opportunity to do some research and find out what it would take to help teachers recognize WHAT those subtle factors are...

    ReplyDelete